Why has female participation in water management in Ghana failed?

Women in Africa hold invaluable knowledge about water and are the biggest users of water in the continent, however, they remain voiceless in decision-making processes and management of water. Women's participation has been associated with the success of water projects. Women played a significant role in decision-making before colonialism, however, during and "post" colonial periods excluded women and maintained gendered power imbalances in society.  

Even though Ghana has an abundance of water availability, the country lacks adequate water access. According to UNICEF, 76% of households in Ghana drink water that is faceally contaminated. Ghana's water management has undergone a series of reforms since its independence in 1957 and has introduced a decentralised approach to water management, entailing the empowerment of local people and increased public participation. Ministry of Women and Children's Affairs (MOWAC) is the department in charge of enforcing the national gender and children's policy, which serves to address women and children's issues across all parts of society.

Women in Ghana, despite their essential role in the country's water society, face significant barriers to participation in water management. Traditional norms and practices in addition to a highly male-dominated society, pose challenges to women's participation in water management. Women's equal participation is also largely hindered by time allocation struggles, which significantly stems from their responsibility to collect water. Much like wider Africa, women in Ghana have limited rights and access to basic resources, including land ownership and access to the labour market, thus reducing their earning capacity. Ghanian women earn on average 25% less than men. 


Village Agricultural Initiatives Project

The Village Agricultural Initiatives Project (VAIP) was established to generate small income-generating projects for women during the drier seasons, using primarily agricultural projects in order to strengthen the economy of the wider community. In East Mamprusi and Yendi, some of these projected included the extraction of shea butter. The principle of participation allows for women in poor village communities to gain managerial skills, allowing them to repair and manage their water sources. However, this project, like other projects aimed at female inclusion and participation in Ghana, failed. The emphasis on participation, empowerment and sustainability highlights their lack of consideration of wider structural causes of poverty and gendered power inequalities. 

Water provision and poverty

There is a water tariff on drinking water in many societies, which is a part of the financial management of the water source. Women frequently face difficulties making payments due to their limited economic capital. Consequently, they continue to be restricted to water collection. Despite having relatively less financial means, women pay the water tariff, men continue to be unbothered about how their spouse acquires the means to pay and women continue to be burdened with water collection responsibilities. As women heavily rely on water collection, water projects such as the implementation of taps and boreholes, will not be as successful as anticipated because they will be unable to pay the tariffs. Women are critical in acknowledging who is poor. The UN states that water is a right, however, because some poor women cannot afford the amount of water that is required for basic sanitation and hydration needs, there should be exceptions on payments. By including women in water management, we can ensure that the right to water is achieved. 

Conclusion

The central government needs to establish improved laws and legislations that actively enforce women's rights to participate in water management and other aspects of management are urgently needed. Furthermore, women should be greeted with incentives to engage in water supply management and decision-making, which would ultimately outweigh the burden that their participation entails. Implementing women's participation in water management will be difficult without the laws explicitly promoting female participation. However, gendered imbalances in Ghana in Integrated Water Resource Management are difficult to overcome regardless of laws and national plans for gendered inclusivity because the projects are underfunded. 

Comments

  1. Greta Feddersen4 January 2022 at 01:55

    Excellent post. I like how you both pointed out the advantages of VAIP, however you were also critical in its disadvantages. Your post allowed me to understand how engrained gender power inequalities still exist within such schemes which are ultimately aimed at increasing female participation and inclusion. There is no simple solution, however raising awareness about the gender imbalances which currently exist in integrated water resource management schemes in Ghana is a step forward!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Arzoo5 January 2022 at 08:54

      Hi Greta. I think raising awareness is definitely so important in achieving inclusive water management schemes. However, solidifying gender-mainstreaming in government policy should also be a priority to ensure participation is approached appropriately.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

WaSH and gender-based violence

Image
Understated violence behind water collection and toilet facilities  Patriarchy comes in all forms. Patriarchal violence is undoubtedly the most gruesome form of sexism, one that is routine everywhere in the world. Women and girls collecting water and practising open defecation in Africa are not safe: they are commonly greeted with male violence at water point queues, water fetching paths and open defecation routes. Women are also subjected to domestic abuse when they fail to gather enough water to complete their domestic responsibilities. Thus it is important to adopt an "engendered" interpretation of the right to sanitation.  Why do women practice open defecation? Open defecation is a product of patriarchy: the lack of consideration of differential gendered sanitation needs and the dominance of men in decision making in both the domestic and public sphere means toilet facilities are not designed to meet the basic sanitation needs of women. The topic of open defecation is com...
Read more

Climate change: another gendered issue

Image
Why African women need to be included in climate change discourse The Sahel region is a  hotspot for climate change : temperatures increase  1.5 times quicker than the rest of the world.   Approximately 65% of the population in the Sahel live in rural areas, with a vast majority of communities being prone to intense droughts, desertification and floods. Rural communities rely on agriculture as it is the most significant economic sector. Since 2015, 36/46 of sub-Saharan African countries formally addressed climate change through their policies and laws, however, only 3 of these countries (Mali, Malawi and Nigeria) have emphasised the need to address gendered-climate justice. Women in this region account for 80% of the agricultural labour force and are thus disproportionately disadvantaged by climate change. Women bear the brunt of climate issues because they h old positions burned by environmental change,  including water collection and agriculture. For example,...
Read more

The weight of the world on their backs

Image
Why does water collection labour require gender and child-centred perspective?  Women and children bear the brunt of water labour. A study of six rural communities in South Africa shows that 56% of women and 31% of young girls carried the burden of collecting water compared to only 10% of young boys and 3% of men. The most significant factor influencing the role of a child's contribution to water collection is their gender . Children typically leave school early to look after younger siblings while the mothers collect water, alternatively, they leave school to collect water themselves. This impacts their studies significantly as they are left fatigued and many reported difficulties concentrating at school. Women often experience conflict at water points, which commonly results in physical or sexual assault - the perceived fear of assault alone demonstrates the urgency of safer ways to have access to water. Health risks associated with water collection  In sub-Saharan Africa, ...
Read more